Year

Result

1914

Brooklyn Field Club 2, Brooklyn Celtic 1

1915

Bethlehem Steel 3, Brooklyn Celtic 1

1916

Bethlehem Steel 1, Fall River Rovers  0

1917

Fall River Rovers 1, Bethlehem Steel 0

1918

Bethlehem Steel  2, Fall River Rovers 
Bethlehem Steel  3, Fall River Rovers  0

1919

Bethlehem Steel  2, Paterson FC  0

Year

Result

1920

St. Louis Ben Millers  2, Fore River  1

1921

Brooklyn Robins Dry Dock  4, St. Louis Scullin Steel  2

1922

St. Louis Scullins Steel  3, Brooklyn Todd Shipyards  2

1923*

Paterson FC  2, St. Louis Scullin Steel 2

1924

Fall River Marksmen  4, St. Louis Vesper Buick 2

1925

Shawsheen (Mass.) Indians 3, Chicago Canadian Club 0

1926

Bethlehem Steel  7, St. Louis Ben Millers  2

1927

Fall River Marksmen  7, Detroit Holley Carburetor 0

1928

New York Nationals  2, Chicago Bricklayers 2
New York Nationals  3, Chicago Bricklayers 0

1929

New York Hakoah  2, St. Louis Madison Kennels 0
New York Hakoah  3, St. Louis Madison kennels 0

Year

Result

1930

Fall River Marksmen  7, Cleveland Bruell Insurance 2
Fall River Marksmen  2, Cleveland Bruell Insurance 1

1931

Fall River F. C.  6, Chicago Bricklayers 2
Fall River F. C.  1, Chicago Bricklayers 1
Fall River F. C.  2, Chicago Bricklayers 0

1932

New Bedford Whalers  3, St. Louis Stix, Baer & Fuller  3
New Bedford Whalers  5, St. Louis Stix, Baer & Fuller  2

1933

St. Louis Stix, Baer & Fuller (SLSL) 1, New York Americans (ASL I) 0
St. Louis Stix, Baer & Fuller (SLSL) 2, New York Americans 1

1934

St. Louis Stix, Baer & Fuller (SLSL) 4, Pawtucket Rangers (ASL-NE) 2
St. Louis Stix, Baer & Fuller (SLSL) 2, Pawtucket Rangers (ASL-NE) 3
St. Louis Stix, Baer & Fuller 5, Pawtucket Rangers (ASL-NE) 0

1935

St. Louis Central Breweries 5, Pawtucket Rangers (ASL-NE) 2
St. Louis Central Breweries 1, Pawtucket Rangers (ASL-NE) 1
St. Louis Central Breweries 1, Pawtucket Rangers (ASL-NE) 3

1936

Philadelphia German-American 2, St. Louis Shamrocks 2
Philadelphia German-American 3, St. Louis Shamrocks 1

1937

New York Americans (ASL II) 0, St. Louis Shamrocks 1
New York Americans (ASL II) 4, St. Louis Shamrocks 1

1938

Chicago Sparta (NSL) 4, Brooklyn St. Mary's Celtic (ASL II) 0
Chicago Sparta (NSL) 4, Brooklyn St. Mary's Celtic (ASL II) 2

1939

Brooklyn St. Mary's Celtic (ASL II) 1, Chicago Manhattan Beer 0
Brooklyn St. Mary's Celtic (ASL II) 4, Chicago Manhattan Beer 1

Year

Result

1940**

Baltimore SC (ASL II) 0, Chicago Sparta A & BA (NSL) 0
Baltimore SC (ASL II) 2, Chicago Sparta A & BA (NSL) 2

1941

Pawtucket FC (ASL-NE) 4, Detroit Chrysler 2
Pawtucket FC (ASL-NE) 4, Detroit Chrysler 3

1942

Pittsburgh Gallatin SC 2, Pawtucket FC 1
Pittsburgh Gallatin SC 4, Pawtucket FC 2

1943

Brooklyn Hio (ASL II) 2, Pittsburgh Morgan-Strasser 2
Brooklyn Hio (ASL II) 3, Pittsburgh Morgan-Strasser 2

1944

Brooklyn Hio (ASL II) 4, Pittsburgh Morgan-Strasser 0

1945

New York Brookhattan (ASL II) 4, Cleveland Americans 1
New York Brookhattan (ASL II) 2, Cleveland Americans 1

1946

Chicago Viking  1, Fall River Ponta Delgada 1
Chicago Viking 2, Fall river Ponta Delgada 1

1947

Fall River Ponta Delgada 6, Chicago Sparta A & BA 1
Fall River Ponta Delgada 3, Chicago Sparta A & BA 2

1948

St. Louis Simpkins-Ford 3, New York Brookhattan 2

1949

Pittsburgh Morgan SC 0, Philadelphia Nationals 1

Year

Result

1950

St. Louis Simpkins-Ford 2, Fall River Ponta Delgada 0
St. Louis Simpkins-Ford 1, Fall River Ponta Delgada 1

1951

New York German-Hungarian 2, Pittsburgh Heidelberg 4
New York German-Hungarian 6, Pittsburgh Heidelberg 2

1952

Pittsburgh Hamarville 3, Philadelphia Nationals 4
Pittsburgh Hamarville 4, Philadelphia Nationals 1

1953

Chicago Falcons 2, Pittsburgh Hamarville 0
Chicago Falcons 1, Pittsburgh Hamarville 1

1954

New York Americans 1, St. Louis Kutis 0
New York Americans 2, St. Louis Kutis 0

1955

S.C. Eintracht (GAL) 2, Los Angeles Danish Americans 0

1956

Pittsburgh Hamarville 0, Chicago Schwaben 1
Pittsburgh Hamarville 3, Chicago Schwaben 1

1957

St. Louis Kutis 3, New York Hakoah 0
St. Louis Kutis 3, New York Hakoah 1

1958

Los Angeles Kickers 2, Baltimore Pompei 1

1959

San Pedro McIlvane Canvasbacks 4, Fall River SC 3

Year

Result

1960

Philadelphia Ukrainian Nationals 5, Los Angeles Kickers 3

1961

Philadelphia Ukrainian Nationals 2, Los Angeles Scots 2
Philadelphia Ukrainian Nationals 5, Los Angeles Scots 2

1962

New York Hungaria 3, San Francisco Scots 2

1963

Philadelphia Ukrainian Nationals 1, Los Angeles Armenian 0

1964

Los Angeles Kickers 2, Philadelphia Ukrainian Nationals 2
Los Angeles Kickers 2, Philadelphia Ukrainian Nationals 0

1965

New York Ukrainians 1, Chicago Hansa 1
New York Ukrainians 3, Chicago Hansa 0

1966

Philadelphia Ukrainian Nationals 1, Orange County 0
Philadelphia Ukrainian Nationals 3, Orange County 0

1967

New York Greek-American 4, Orange County 2

1968

New York Greek American 1, Chicago Olympic 1
New York Greek-American 1, Chicago Olympic 0

1969

New York Greek-American 1, Montabello Armenians 0

Year

Result

1970

S.C. Elizabeth 2, Los Angeles Croatia 1

1971

New York Hota 6, San Pedro Yugoslavs 4

1972

S.C. Elizabeth 1, San Pedro Yugoslavs 0

1973

Los Angeles Maccabee 5, Cleveland Inter 3

1974

New York Greek-American 2, Chicago Croatia 0

1975

Los Angeles Maccabee 1, New York Inter-Giuliana 0

1976

San Francisco A. C. 1, New York Inter-Giuliana 0

1977

Los Angeles Maccabee 5, Philadelphia United German-Hungarian 1

1978

Los Angeles Maccabee 2, Bridgeport Vasco de Gama 0

1979

Brooklyn Dodgers 2, Chicago Croatian 1

Year

Result

1980

New York Pancyprian Freedoms 3, Los Angeles Maccabee 2

1981

Los Angeles Maccabee 5, Brooklyn Dodgers 1

1982

New York Pancyprian Freedoms 4, Los Angeles Maccabee 3

1983

New York Pancyprian Freedoms 4, St. Louis Kutis 3

1984

New York A.O. Krete 4, Chicago Croatian 2

1985

San Francisco Greek-American A.C. 2, St. Louis Kutis 1

1986

St. Louis Kutis 1, San Pedro Yugoslavs 0

1987

Washington Club Ea 1, Seattle Eagles 0

1988

St. Louis Busch Seniors 1, San Francisco Greek-American 0

1989

St. Petersburg Kickers 2, New York Greek-American/Atlas (CSL) 1

Year

Result

1990

Chicago A.A.C. Eagles 2, Brooklyn Italians 1

1991

Brooklyn Italians 1, Richardson  Rockets 0

1992

San Jose Oaks 2, Bridgeport Vasco de Gama 1

1993

San Francisco CD Mexico 5, Philadelphia United German-Hungarians 0

1994

San Francisco Greek-American 3, Milwaukee Bavarian Leinenkugel 0

1995

Richmond Kickers (USISL) 1, El Paso Patriots (USISL) 1 (4:2 penalties)

1996

D.C. United (MLS) 3, Rochester Rhinos (A-League) 0

1997

Dallas Burn (MLS) 0, DC United (MLS) 0 (5:3 penalties)

1998

Chicago Fire (MLS) 2, Columbus Crew (MLS) 1 (overtime)

1999

Rochester Rhinos (A) 2, Colorado Rapids (MLS) 0

Year

Result

2000

Chicago Fire (MLS) 2, Miami Fusion (MLS) 1

2001

Los Angeles Galaxy (MLS) 2, New England Revolution (MLS) 1 (overtime)

2002

Columbus Crew (MLS) 1, Los Angeles Galaxy (MLS) 0

2003

Chicago Fire (MLS) 1, New York MetroStars (MLS) 0

2004

Kansas City Wizards (MLS) 1, Chicago Fire (MLS) 0 (aet)

2005

Los Angeles Galaxy (MLS) 1, FC Dallas (MLS) 2

2006

Chicago Fire (MLS) 3, Los Angeles Galaxy (MLS) 1

2007

New England Revolution (MLS) 3, FC Dallas (MLS) 2

2008

D.C. United (MLS) 2, Charleston Battery (USL) 1